Landlord is taking $150 out of security deposit for “smoke detector installation”. Is this normal?

Read the Story

Show Top Comments

Definitely not normal to charge for the smoke detectors


If it’s not in the lease they can’t make you pay for it. A smoke detector has to be replaced every 10 years and they have a built in testing feature. They are also only about $15 each. This guy is 100% scamming you, but your question would be better on /r/legaladvice


Safety equipment should be updated/upgraded/installed and paid for by the landlord.


CA has great tenant protections so you may have that on your side. I don’t believe that is a fair or normal practice for the smoke detectors unless you were responsible for the replacement being needed. Also if the shelf in the garage was pre-existing before you signed the lease, why should you pay for its removal?


Given that you are in CA, this is illegal. Installation of smoke detectors is 100% the responsibility of the landlord. Kindly remind him of that fact.